Most Any Reason Is Better than None: Consequences of Implausible Reasons and Warrants in Brief Written Arguments

Autor/inn/en	Wolfe, Christopher R.; Gao, Hongli; Wu, Minhua; Albrecht, Michael
Titel	Most Any Reason Is Better than None: Consequences of Implausible Reasons and Warrants in Brief Written Arguments
Quelle	In: Written Communication, 35 (2018) 3, S.255-285 (31 Seiten) PDF als Volltext Verfügbarkeit
Sprache	englisch
Dokumenttyp	gedruckt; online; Zeitschriftenaufsatz
ISSN	0741-0883
DOI	10.1177/0741088318767370
Schlagwörter	Persuasive Discourse; Writing (Composition); Hypothesis Testing; Majors (Students); Foreign Countries; Undergraduate Students; Statistical Analysis; United States History; Environment; China; Ohio + Suchen Sie Ihr Suchwort? Persuasion; Persuasive Kommunikation; Schreibübung; Hypothesenprüfung; Hypothesentest; Ausland; Statistische Analyse; Umwelt
Abstract	Argumentation schema theory guided four experiments on the processing of plausible and implausible reasons and warrant statements testing the hypothesis that most reasons produce greater agreement with claims than when claims are presented without support. Another hypothesis was that leaving warrants unstated often produces greater agreement than when the warrant is made explicit. In Study 1, American participants were more likely to agree with claims after they read arguments than beforehand--even those with implausible reasons and warrants. In Study 2, American history and environmental science majors read brief arguments and agreed more with implausible arguments than claims alone. Study 3, with Chinese participants, replicated some but not all earlier results. In Study 4, with Chinese participants, blatantly false claims supported by bogus reasons yielded marginally greater agreement than unsupported claims. These findings suggest that many people have uncritical argumentation schemata with low support thresholds, making them vulnerable to weak and bogus arguments. (As Provided).
Anmerkungen	SAGE Publications. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks, CA 91320. Tel: 800-818-7243; Tel: 805-499-9774; Fax: 800-583-2665; e-mail: journals@sagepub.com; Web site: http://sagepub.com
Erfasst von	ERIC (Education Resources Information Center), Washington, DC
Update	2020/1/01