Suche

Wo soll gesucht werden?
Erweiterte Literatursuche

Ariadne Pfad:

Inhalt

Literaturnachweis - Detailanzeige

 
Autor/inn/enGarcia-Mila, Merce; Gilabert, Sandra; Erduran, Sibel; Felton, Mark
TitelThe Effect of Argumentative Task Goal on the Quality of Argumentative Discourse.
QuelleIn: Science education, 97 (2013) 4, S. 497-523Infoseite zur Zeitschrift
PDF als Volltext  Link als defekt meldenVerfügbarkeit 
Spracheenglisch
Dokumenttyponline; gedruckt; Zeitschriftenaufsatz
ISSN0036-8326; 1098-237X
DOI10.1002/sce.21057
SchlagwörterJunior High School; Klassengespräch; Unterrichtsgespräch; Argumentation; Diskursanalyse; Energiequelle; Naturwissenschaftliche Bildung; Naturwissenschaftlicher Unterricht; Physikunterricht; Wissenschaftliche Kommunikation; Argumentationstechnik
AbstractIn argumentative discourse, there are two kinds of activity-dispute and deliberation-that depend on the argumentative task goal. In dispute the goal is to defend a conclusion by undermining alternatives, whereas in deliberation the goal is to arrive at a conclusion by contrasting alternatives. In this study, we examine the impact of these tasks goals on the quality of argumentative discourse. Sixty-five junior high school students were organized into dyads to discuss sources of energy. Dyads were formed by members who had differing viewpoints and were distributed to one of two conditions: 31 dyads were asked to discuss with the goal to persuade the partner, and 34 were asked to reach consensus. Argumentation was analyzed using a schema based on Toulmin (1958). Eleven different argumentative structures resulted from the combination of Toulmin's basic elements. Students in the consensus group scored significantly higher than students in the persuasion group in 5/6 argumentative structures that included rebuttals. The major implication of the present work is that, similar to Mercer's (2000) claim about types of classroom conversation, not all classroom argumentation tasks promote scientific reasoning equally.
Erfasst vonArbeitsgruppe Didaktik der Physik, Universität Kassel
Update2014/3
Literaturbeschaffung und Bestandsnachweise in Bibliotheken prüfen
 

Standortunabhängige Dienste
Bibliotheken, die die Zeitschrift "Science education" besitzen:
Link zur Zeitschriftendatenbank (ZDB)

Artikellieferdienst der deutschen Bibliotheken (subito):
Übernahme der Daten in das subito-Bestellformular

Tipps zum Auffinden elektronischer Volltexte im Video-Tutorial

Trefferlisten Einstellungen

Permalink als QR-Code

Permalink als QR-Code

Inhalt auf sozialen Plattformen teilen (nur vorhanden, wenn Javascript eingeschaltet ist)

Teile diese Seite: